Anderson v. Intel 401(k) Supreme Court Case: Latest Update

Anderson v. Intel is a U.S. Supreme Court case about when a worker can sue over a 401(k) investment that underperformed. The Court heard arguments on October 6, 2026, and has not ruled yet. The question is whether a plaintiff must point to a meaningful benchmark, meaning a comparable fund with similar goals and risks, before a court lets an underperformance claim go forward. Most observers expect the Court to side with Intel, though the exact definition of “meaningful” is still open. A decision is likely by the end of the Court’s term in mid 2027.

Few cases this term matter as much to the people who run, and the people who save in, workplace retirement plans. In Anderson v. Intel, former Intel employees say the company’s investment committee put part of their 401(k) money into hedge funds and private equity, and that the results lagged behind simpler funds while costing more. Intel says the strategy was designed to cushion savers from steep market drops, and that comparing it to plain stock funds is unfair. After the October 6 argument, several justices across the usual ideological lines sounded doubtful about the workers’ position. Whatever the final wording, the ruling will shape what a 401(k) lawsuit must show at its very first stage. We’ll be updating this article monthly.

The Department of Labor is working on a separate rule that would give plan sponsors a safe harbor when they pick investment options, including private market funds, and it filed a brief in July urging the Court to back Intel. Lawyers on both sides say the two tracks are linked. A tough benchmark rule from the Court would make it harder to bring cases over unusual strategies, while the Labor Department’s proposal would make it easier for employers to offer them. This guide covers where the case stands, what the justices said, who is affected and what workers and employers can do now.

Anderson v. Intel Key Highlights

ItemDetail
Case nameAnderson v. Intel Corporation Investment Policy Committee
Supreme Court docket number25-498
Lower court rulingNinth Circuit affirmed dismissal on May 22, 2025
Certiorari grantedJanuary 16, 2026
Oral argumentOctober 6, 2026
Decision statusPending as of November 20, 2026
Core questionMust plaintiffs plead a meaningful benchmark in an underperformance claim?
Law at issueEmployee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) duty of prudence
Federal government positionSupports Intel

Anderson v. Intel Key Dates

DateWhat happened
August 2019Former Intel participant Winston Anderson files the lawsuit
May 22, 2025Ninth Circuit upholds dismissal
October 20, 2025Workers ask the Supreme Court to hear the case
January 16, 2026Supreme Court agrees to hear it
March 30, 2026Labor Department proposes a safe harbor for picking 401(k) investments
April 23, 2026Workers file their opening brief
June 1, 2026Comment period on the Labor Department proposal closes
July 2026Intel and the federal government file briefs supporting the company
August 3, 2026Workers file their reply brief
October 6, 2026Oral argument at the Supreme Court
By mid 2027Decision expected before the term ends

What Is Anderson v. Intel About?

The case began as a proposed class action under ERISA, the federal law that sets standards for private retirement plans. Winston Anderson, a former participant in Intel’s 401(k) savings plan, sued the committee that oversees the plan’s investments. He raised two kinds of claims. The first is about prudence: that the committee breached its duty by putting a share of the plan’s custom target date funds and a global diversified fund into hedge funds and private equity. The second is about loyalty: that the committee favored companies backed by Intel Capital, the company’s venture arm.

According to legal summaries, Intel redesigned its funds after the 2008 market crash to add alternative assets, with the stated goal of reducing volatility and limiting large losses. The workers say the approach produced higher fees and returns that trailed peer funds. The company says protecting savers in down markets was the point, and that a fund built for that purpose cannot fairly be judged against a fund built purely for growth.

The case has been long. It stretched across almost six years and three versions of the complaint at the trial level before the Ninth Circuit weighed in. The district court dismissed it, allowed an amended complaint, and dismissed again with prejudice.

State Auto-IRA Programs: Which States Require Employers to Offer One?

What Did the Ninth Circuit Decide in Anderson v. Intel?

In its May 22, 2025 ruling, reported at 137 F.4th 1015, the Ninth Circuit held that a worker who claims a fund was imprudent because it underperformed needs to identify a meaningful benchmark. That means a comparison investment with similar objectives and risk, not just any fund that happened to do better.

The panel found that Anderson fell short. He relied on circumstantial arguments rather than facts about how Intel’s committee actually chose investments, and he compared Intel’s blended funds to equity heavy retail funds that had different aims. The court rejected index funds, Morningstar peer groups and other target date products as unsuitable comparators. On the loyalty claim, it found only a possible conflict of interest, with no facts showing that Intel influenced which startups received funding.

One detail matters for later: the ruling did not close the door on every case. A concurring opinion by Judge Berzon noted that a worker can still argue imprudence through other circumstantial facts that point to a flawed decision making process. A benchmark is one route into court, not the only one.

What the Supreme Court Is Deciding?

The question the justices agreed to answer is narrow but important. When a plaintiff says a plan fiduciary acted imprudently because an investment underperformed, must the complaint include a meaningful benchmark to survive a motion to dismiss? If so, what makes a benchmark meaningful?

This is a pleading question, not a verdict on whether Intel’s strategy was wise. A motion to dismiss is the first test a defendant can raise, before any documents are exchanged or witnesses questioned. Because discovery in a retirement plan case is expensive, the standard at this early stage often decides whether a case is ever heard on its merits.

The Circuit Split Behind the Case

Federal appeals courts have not agreed on how strict to be. Based on the case summaries available, the Eighth Circuit in Meiners v. Wells Fargo (2018), the Third Circuit in Sweda v. University of Pennsylvania (2019), the Seventh Circuit in Albert v. Oshkosh (2022) and the Tenth Circuit in Matney v. Barrick Gold (2023) have all required or leaned on a comparator. The Sixth Circuit took a looser view in Johnson v. Parker-Hannifin (2024), saying a benchmark may be a building block and is often necessary, but not always required, with the focus on how fiduciaries made decisions at the time.

That mix is the main reason the Supreme Court took the case. Lower court judges, lawyers and plan committees have been working from different rulebooks.

What the Justices Said at Oral Argument?

The hearing on October 6 offered the best preview of how the Court may rule. The recaps below come from legal commentators, not an official transcript.

JusticeReported focus
ThomasBacked the Ninth Circuit and said a claim cannot compare apples and oranges
AlitoSaw no reason to reject the Ninth Circuit approach and asked about risk adjusted analysis by experts
KaganCalled the Ninth Circuit ruling pretty reasonable, but said the comparator must be an apple, not necessarily the same apple
GorsuchGot workers’ counsel to agree some comparison is needed
SotomayorAsked how to define the right comparator and noted the complaint does not clearly name one
BarrettNoted both sides agree a benchmark is needed and disagree on what meaningful means
KavanaughAsked why underperformance matters, since about half of funds fall below the median
RobertsAsked how narrowly the standard should be written

Representing the workers was Matthew Wessler of Gupta Wessler. Charles McCloud of Williams & Connolly argued for Intel, and Aimee Brown of the Solicitor General’s office argued in support of the company. She said prudence is about a fiduciary’s process rather than performance, and said the Labor Department would welcome Supreme Court guidance on what “meaningful” requires.

Who Is Likely to Win Anderson v. Intel?

No one can say for certain, and a decision could come with surprises. Still, the early read is consistent. A Sidley Austin partner said the Court appeared poised to rule for Intel, and other firms predicted the Ninth Circuit would be affirmed. Commentators from the pro-participant side, such as Sanford Heisler Sharp McKnight, suggested the Court might define “meaningful” and send the case back to the Ninth Circuit rather than end it outright.

The most likely outcome, based on the argument, is a ruling that a comparator is required but need not be identical. Under that view, a fund with like aims and strategies would qualify. The hard part is what “like” means for a hedge fund or private equity holding, where public comparison funds are scarce. Expect the final opinion to spend most of its energy on that line.

What Anderson v. Intel Means for 401(k) Lawsuits

If the Court affirms the Ninth Circuit, workers who sue over underperformance will need to find a truly comparable fund before they get past the first stage. That would make some cases harder to file, particularly those about customized or niche investments. Plan sponsors and their lawyers would likely cite the ruling in motions to dismiss, and some lower courts holding pending motions may act once the decision arrives.

If the workers win, courts would likely treat a comparison as helpful but not mandatory, looking at the whole complaint instead. That would keep more cases alive and raise legal costs for employers.

Either way, lawyers say the underlying duties under ERISA have not changed. The core idea is still that a fiduciary must act with prudence, judged by the information available at the time, not with hindsight. As one lawyer quoted in trade coverage put it, ERISA does not require picking only winners.

What Anderson v. Intel Means for Your 401(k) Account

For most savers, nothing changes today. Your plan’s investment lineup, fees and contribution limits stay as they are, and the Supreme Court has not ordered any change to any plan. The effect is indirect.

A strict benchmark rule could slow the number of lawsuits over complex investments, which employers say has kept private market funds out of 401(k) plans. The Labor Department, in its March 2026 proposal, pointed to more than 500 lawsuits since 2016 and more than $1 billion in ERISA settlements since 2020 as part of the reason. Supporters of the case for Intel argue a clearer rule lets employers offer a wider menu. Critics, including AARP and several law professors who filed briefs for the workers, worry that fewer lawsuits means fewer checks on high fees and weak funds.

For workers, the practical takeaway is simple. Watch your fees, understand what each fund is built to do, and read the notices your plan sends each year.

OPM Retirement Backlog 2026: Current Wait Times

How the DOL Safe Harbor Rule Connects to Anderson v. Intel

On March 30, 2026, the Labor Department proposed a rule titled Fiduciary Duties in Selecting Designated Investment Alternatives, published at 91 Fed. Reg. 16088. Public comments closed on June 1, 2026. The proposal would give fiduciaries a presumption of prudence if they carefully evaluate six factors when choosing an investment option.

Safe harbor factorWhat a fiduciary would weigh
Expected performanceWhether the option is likely to meet its goals
Fees and expensesTotal cost to participants
LiquidityHow easily money can be withdrawn or sold
ValuationHow the holdings are priced
BenchmarkingWhich standard the option is measured against
ComplexityWhether participants and the committee can understand it

The factors are not an exhaustive list. The rule applies to all investment choices in participant directed plans, not only to alternative assets such as private equity, private credit, real estate or digital assets. It follows Executive Order 14330, signed in August 2025, which asked regulators to ease access to alternatives in retirement plans.

The link to Anderson v. Intel is benchmarking. Commenters asked the Labor Department to explain how a sponsor should pick a fair benchmark, and some lawyers expect the agency to wait for the Court before finalizing. Others note the rule could come first, possibly before the end of 2026, and that the Court is unlikely to decide before then. The rule remains a proposal, and it can still change.

Anderson v. Intel Decision Date: When to Expect a Ruling

The Court usually issues opinions in argued cases by the end of June or the first days of July. Trade coverage after the hearing pointed to a decision around then, though one expert noted it could arrive sooner, and another said observers expect a ruling “in the spring.” Because the opinion could include a new definition of a key term, it may take longer to write, and more than one justice may write separately.

The best place to check is the Supreme Court’s own opinions page and docket for case 25-498, linked in the table of official resources below. As of November 20, 2026, no decision appears in the docket content reviewed for this article.

What Happens After the Ruling?

A decision does not end the story. If the Court affirms, the dismissal stands and the case effectively ends for these plaintiffs, though the opinion will guide others. If the Court vacates the Ninth Circuit’s judgment and sends the case back, the lower court would need to apply the new standard, which can take many months. Courts across the country would then begin to cite the opinion, and employers would adjust their documentation and committee procedures.

A rough path looks like this: decision in mid 2027, lower courts apply the standard through late 2027 and 2028, and the Labor Department finalizes or revises its rule on its own schedule. There is no payment or claim process tied to the Supreme Court decision, because Anderson v. Intel is not a settlement. No money is being distributed to anyone, and no one needs to file anything to take part.

How to Check Your Own Plan for Risk?

You do not need to file a claim to stay informed, but you can look at your plan with fresh eyes. These steps work for any 401(k).

  1. Log in to your plan website and open the fund lineup, noting each fund’s expense ratio.
  2. Read each fund’s fact sheet to see what it is built to do and what benchmark it uses.
  3. Review your annual fee disclosure, which your plan is required to send.
  4. Compare any fund you are unsure about with a similar fund by objective and risk, not just by last year’s return.
  5. Ask your benefits team for the plan’s investment policy statement if you want to see how funds are chosen and reviewed.
  6. If you believe plan money is being mishandled, contact the Labor Department’s benefits advisors at 1-866-444-3272.

Remember that a poor year does not prove a fund is imprudent, and the Court is likely to say that clearly.

Fee and Underperformance Calculator

Small gaps in fees and returns add up over decades, which is why these cases exist. Lets you enter a balance, yearly contribution, time horizon, a baseline return and two annual cost levels. It shows what your account could look like under each and how much the difference costs. It is an illustration of compounding, not a legal tool, and it cannot tell you whether any fund was imprudent.

401(k) Fee and Underperformance Calculator

An illustration of compounding. It cannot tell you whether any fund was imprudent.

What Plan Sponsors and Committees Should Do Now

Trade experts suggest steady, low drama steps instead of sweeping changes before a ruling. Document why each fund was selected and what it is meant to achieve. Choose comparison funds in advance, and write down the reasons. Check that the investment policy statement matches the data the committee actually reviews, a mismatch one fiduciary lawyer called a very common error. Record the committee's process for monitoring and replacing funds, because courts look at process. If alternatives are on the table, plan for the possibility that no public index fits and that you may need to build your own comparison.

Law firms advising clients have also said sponsors do not need to rewrite policies before the Court acts, since the underlying duties are unchanged.

Mistakes to Avoid When Reading the Anderson v. Intel News

Treating oral argument as a ruling. Assuming Intel has already won. Believing the Court is deciding whether private equity belongs in 401(k) plans, when the question is about pleading. Expecting a settlement payment, since none exists. And assuming the Labor Department rule is final, when it is still a proposal.

Social Security Trust Fund 2032: Will Your Benefits Be Cut?

Official Resources and Links

ResourceUse it forLink
Supreme Court docket 25-498Briefs, argument date and any decisionhttps://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25-498.html
Question presented (PDF)Exact wording of the issuehttps://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/qp/25-00498qp.pdf
Supreme Court opinions pageNew opinions as they are releasedhttps://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/slipopinion/26
Department of Labor amicus releaseGovernment position in the casehttps://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/ebsa/ebsa20260710
EBSA, Employee Benefits Security AdministrationRetirement plan rules and helphttps://www.dol.gov/agencies/ebsa
Ask EBSASubmit a question or complaint about your planhttps://www.askebsa.dol.gov
SCOTUSblog case pageIndependent case coveragehttps://www.scotusblog.com/cases/case-files/anderson-v-intel-corp-investment-policy-comm
Federal RegisterRead the proposed safe harbor rule, 91 Fed. Reg. 16088https://www.federalregister.gov

FAQs About Anderson v. Intel 401(k) Supreme Court Case

What is Anderson v. Intel?

It is a Supreme Court case about whether workers who sue over 401(k) underperformance must name a meaningful benchmark at the start of a case.

Has the Supreme Court decided Anderson v. Intel?

No. Arguments were heard on October 6, 2026, and a decision is expected by mid 2027.

Who is suing Intel?

Winston Anderson, a former participant in Intel's 401(k) savings plan, on behalf of a proposed class.

What are the workers claiming?

They say plan fiduciaries invested in hedge funds and private equity that cost more and trailed other funds, and that the committee favored companies tied to Intel Capital.

What is a meaningful benchmark?

A comparison fund with similar goals, strategy and risk. The justices are still working out how close the match must be.

Does this ruling change my 401(k)?

Not directly. It affects who can sue and how, rather than your investments.

Is there a settlement or payout?

No. Anderson v. Intel is a pleading dispute, and no claims process exists.

Is Anderson v. Intel decided?

Not yet. The Court heard arguments on October 6, 2026.

Why did the Supreme Court take the Intel 401(k) case?

Appeals courts disagreed on whether a benchmark is required, and the Court agreed on January 16, 2026 to settle the split.

Who is expected to win Anderson v. Intel?

Early commentary favored Intel after the argument, but the Court has not ruled and could narrow or shape the standard.

Can I sue my employer over 401(k) losses?

Possibly, but you generally need to show a breach of fiduciary duty, not just a loss. Speak with a qualified attorney, and note that the process for choosing funds is central.

Are private equity and hedge funds allowed in 401(k) plans?

ERISA does not ban specific investment types, and a Labor Department proposal aims to make it easier for fiduciaries to include them. Many plans still avoid them because of litigation risk.

What is the DOL safe harbor for 401(k) investments?

It is a proposed rule that would presume a fiduciary acted prudently after weighing six factors: expected performance, fees, liquidity, valuation, benchmarking and complexity.

What does ERISA require of plan fiduciaries?

Acting with the care and prudence of an expert in a similar role, based on what was known when the decision was made.

How can I find out my 401(k) fees?

Check your plan's annual fee disclosure and each fund's expense ratio on its fact sheet.

Conclusion

Anderson v. Intel is a pleading case with big consequences. The Supreme Court is deciding how much a worker must show about comparable funds before a 401(k) claim can proceed, and the argument suggested the Ninth Circuit's benchmark rule will largely stand, with the final word on "meaningful" still to come. For savers, nothing changes in your account today. For employers, the outcome will influence how freely they offer complex funds and how they document investment decisions.

Keep an eye on the Supreme Court docket for the opinion, and on the Labor Department's final safe harbor rule, which could land before or after it. If you have concerns about your own plan, review your fees, read your plan notices and speak with a qualified attorney or the Labor Department. This article is general information, not legal or financial advice.

Social Security Payment Dates for December 2026: Know Full Schedule by Birthday

Author

  • Mario Marie

    Mario Marie writes about Social Security, SSI, SSDI, Medicare and other U.S. government benefit programs at USA Benefits Now. With four years of professional experience, including work in the banking sector, Mario focuses on explaining payments, deadlines and eligibility rules in plain language, and links to the official source (SSA, CMS, IRS) in every article.

2 thoughts on “Anderson v. Intel 401(k) Supreme Court Case: Latest Update”

Leave a Comment